Question Cesar Millan, the Dog Whisperer's observations stated as facts

On his website, Cesar Millan stated the following:

“I don’t know what dogs dream, but they are definitely doing something really fun. Most of the time, their legs are moving, and they’re barking. In all my years working with dogs – at one point, I had 65 dogs sleeping with me – I’ve never seen a dog panicking in the middle of his sleep. They just don’t have nightmares like we do. You have to envy that!”

Based on his observations, of sleeping dogs he makes the statement, “They just don’t have nightmares like we do.”

This is flawed thinking, and is an example of an observation being stated as fact. Many dog training theories are stated as facts when, in fact, they are just observations or assumptions.

To scientifically state that dogs “Do not have nightmares like we do” you would have to define the following:

* What a nightmare is
* What physiological changes occur in a person or dog when they are having a nightmare
* How to measure the physiological changes when a person or dog is sleeping to determine if a person or dog is having a nightmare

If you ever hear someone make a statement about dog behavior, do not believe it because they said it or because they have their own television show. Push them for research or ask about the science behind their statement. It is much different to have a theory or make an observation versus having proof.

Examples of statements that are widely used include:

* Walk through doorways before your dog or he will think he is the boss
* Eat before your dog or he will think he is boss
* A dog that is pulling is trying to dominate you
* A dog that mounts you or another dog is trying to be dominant
* My dog “knows what to do” but is ignoring me
* My dog is stubborn

Each of these statements might be true, but they are not based in fact. Many trainers and dog owners have said things like this over the years so many times that they are part of the normal dog training lexicon. But, just because something is repeated many times does not make it true. The earth is flat, right?

Not using hand signals in dog training? – you ar...
You just punished your dog for behaving

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Back to top